Cargo Liners

Hi all,
Just wanted to check with everyone before I purchased a cargo liner for my husband's birthday next month. I'm thinking of going with the MacNeil, but I was also considering the Huskey liner. Thanks for any advice.

I bought the Mcneil, and am very satisified w/ it. I've read other's people's posts who have bought the Husksy and were not happy w/ how thin it was. They also said it was made out of a hard plastic and not rubber (as opposed to the Mcneil).

Not sure where info came from on previous post???
The Husky liner is thicker and is very pliable like rubber although maybe not rubber...real strong and fits perfect.

I have used Husky liners for years in various vehicles. This is my second X and I abuse the heck out of them. I have them front rear and cargo. Never had a problem and they protect from the Red Texas mud and retain water and spills fine.

I guess it depends on use but I camp and off road a lot and LOVE them. One of my best and favorite accessories.

Can't talk about MacNeils because I have never seen or looked at them, Just my .02