Not sure where info came from on previous post???
The Husky liner is thicker and is very pliable like rubber although maybe not rubber...real strong and fits perfect.
I have used Husky liners for years in various vehicles. This is my second X and I abuse the heck out of them. I have them front rear and cargo. Never had a problem and they protect from the Red Texas mud and retain water and spills fine.
I guess it depends on use but I camp and off road a lot and LOVE them. One of my best and favorite accessories.
Can't talk about MacNeils because I have never seen or looked at them, Just my .02
_________________________
"Caribbean Soul land locked in Texas"