Well rather than get into a pissing fight over this, lets come at it from another view.

I think any law that criminalizes a large segment of it's population is going to have a tough time being inforced, especially given the ease of sharing via the net.

Everyone has to determine how they will live their lives. The legality of music sharing is not something I spend much time worrying about.

An excellent 'non-denominational' web site for intellectual property rights info is IP news

Toy Man