I dunno... If you are comparing the X and a scoobie (WRX) those are 2 completely different vehicles.

If you want to go fast, hug corners, and the like, the WRX is probably the way to go.

Otherwise, the X sounds like it is right up your alley.. The only downside I can think of is the MPG. I have a 5 speed in mine, and it is surprisingly fun to drive for a SUV!

Keep your eye out, and you can get a deal.. I paid just over $7K for my '00 (high miles).