Actually, I will probably end up taking it to my local dealer for an estimate. I just wanted a professional opinion on it since we know how insurance companies work(heck, I work for one). They will probably tell me things don't need fixed when they do or give me non-OEM parts...

If my landlord is right(and it seems like he is b/c he came to the same conclusion as I did), I need a new bumper and brackets to mount the bumper b/c they are bent.

I agree dagger...my jaw literally dropped when he tried to hand me $35. I would love to hear his side of the story(and I'm sure I will). How can you hit someone 3 times in a construction zone when you were stopped for 10 minutes?