You're 23. Take the job you'll enjoy most.

Do you want to stay at the same company for the rest of your career? I'm not saying it's necessarily a bad thing, but at your age looking at what's best for retirement isn't always the best thing to do. You've got a lot of living to do before that time, and a lot of things will change between now and then.

Hell, a few years down the road you may decide that you'd be a lot happier in another career, quite a few people do. You might dismiss that today, but sometimes you get the opportunity to try something else that really is more exciting to you.

It's not bad to start planning for retirement at your age, but don't focus on it. It's a long way away, you've got some time.

Another thing is, if this is a large company, maybe that job or something else will be there in a few years if the one you think would be more enjoyable doesn't totally pan out.