Originally posted by cruzinfrontier:
Why can't we compare them? They will be for years to come, might as well start now.
Just one question, would you rather have a win or a QB throw for 400 yards (impressive, btw) and a loss? Right, you want the win.
Vince may not have won the game, but he didn't lose it either, right?
You can start now, but it's not fair to compare records when one actually has a defense and the other does not. Otherwise, going by those standards, you'd rather have Jake Plummer than both of those guys and I hope that's not true.
![[Freak]](graemlins/freak.gif)
It's more fair to compare personal stats. Remember when Peyton Manning didn't have a defense? I'd still rather have him than whoever was hot at the time (Warner?).