Originally posted by eli:
last thing I will say. There have been many great QB's who have not won super bowls, that isn't necessarily a judge of whether the qb is good or not.
Try telling Dan Marino that. Give that man a super bowl and he's titled the greatest quarterback ever. As it is, he sits behind the Montanas and Elways.
Manning and Palmer (who you cited as great qb's, which i agree with) have not won a super bowl, or even been in the game yet. and finally, the other option qb's you cite were simply just not as good as vince. Vic cannot throw, Vince can.
Key word is
yet. You are judged on winning the big games and if they don't win it all, they will also be behind the Elways and Montanas. If you could start a franchise right now and pick any quarterback, I bet those that I named would be higher on the list than VY. If not, I have some beach front property in Lubbock that I'd like to sell you.
Previous Topic
Index
