The average person will most likely be happier with a 2nd gen over a SC. IMO:

The engine, transmission, front suspension, and available traction systems on the 2nd gen's are superior to the 1st.

I prefer the styling/looks, front cab (roomier for big guys), overall exterior size/wheelbase, heaver duty axles/diffs, rear springs, and lever driven tcase on the 1st gen’s.