I debated that for some time as well; as I run the BFG's on my big truck.

However, I went with the highest rated tire in terms of what people are saying about highway, street ride, as well as their belief that the Bridgestone Dueler Revo's were performing better in the snow, rain, sand and could clear mud better then BFG All-terrains. If you go to tirerack.com, and look up the Bridgestone's you can see other people's reviews on these tires.

I for one have had them for about 2 weeks; they're great.