I agree with Scott. I want to leave the spare underneath to allow for better access to the cargo area, but want a rear bumper that gives me recovery and jacking points. Steve, when you say you "could" make a standalone bumper, does that mean it's theoretically possible or that you would be willing to make one? I agree with LAXterra as well, it would be nice to be able to move the tire back and forth. What about the current bumper without the hitch to allow for attaching/detaching the carrier and storing the tire either on the carrier or underneath? Just trying to weigh my options. Thanks for your help.