Mine hasn't arrived yet, but it is due sometime in June.

I ordered the S 4x4 over the Offroad for a few key reasons:

1. Offroad comes with only one choice in interior: Blue cloth with large open loops, which I bet will get pulled and look like crap in a few years.

2. Offroad does not come in Canteen, which would look bad with the blue interior(which I didn't want anyway).

3. After reading the forums, the aftermarket skid plates, although more $$ out of pocket, look much better than the stock.

4. The stiffer ride of the Offroad was a small negative because most of my time will be on the road, and again, if later I feel stiff shocks are important, they can be added.

5. Cost. The offroad would have cost me at least $1500 (retail) more that the S with the same options.

6. It seemed that the HDC and HSA had marginal value, especially after reading these forums.

The biggest concern for the future is the added cost and hassle of adding a rear locker, assuming I get to that point.

Can't wait to get my 05X!