When I called back and asked specifically about the timing belt and the spark plugs, they quoted my a different number: $550 for both.

I'm kind of afraid to ask about the water pump and whatever else because I have a feeling that these guys don't know what the heck they're doing. I asked them about the servicing, and all he said was that they check a bunch of stuff, change the oil, and rotate the tires. So, now either I need to trust them, or I need a list of everything that needs to be done and then go in there with that list.

What. A. Pain.